Collet closer

Making a lever-actuated collet closer

    metal
    machining
Sun Dec 04 2022

I’ve got a 10” 1947 Montgomery Wards (Logan) metal lathe. Like many, I enjoy the convenience and precision of collets. A four-jaw chuck is much more tedious to align, and none of my scroll chucks provide as much precision.

Until recently, I regularly used three different collet systems: 3C, 5C, and ER-32.

The lathe spindle has a 3MT morse-taper at the nose. For years I’ve used 3C collets with an adapter and drawbar. I’ve acquired a full set of 3C collets from 1/16” to 1/2” in 1/64” increments.

3C collet assembly
3C collet assembly
3C collet in situ (forgive the filthy lathe)
3C collet in situ (forgive the filthy lathe)
Drawbar inserted
Drawbar inserted

The main drawback of the 3C collets is the maximum diameter of 1/2”, but the drawbar is also a little slow and tedious to use.

A few years ago I acquired a screw-on 5C collet chuck. This lets me hold onto larger diameter stock, and lets me use the same collets for milling (in collet blocks and indexers, etc.). Unfortunately, there are a couple disadvantages:

  • The collet chuck sticks out too far for a relatively light-weight lathe. I get quite a bit of chatter with parting operations, etc.
  • The scroll takes about a million turns of the chuck key to tighten down on parts.
5C collet chuck
5C collet chuck

I’ve also started using ER-32 collets with an adapter. This lets me hold onto “between” size stock, which is nice, but it also has a few problems:

  • I’ve not made a drawbar, so I just bang the 3MT adapter into the end of the spindle and depend on friction to hold it in place (this works fine in practice).
  • While not as bad as the 5C chuck, the work still sticks out far enough to cause problems with chatter.
ER-32 collet chuck
ER-32 collet chuck

A lever-actuator for 3MT collets

One problem in common with all of the above is that they either depend on screw-in drawbars or scroll chucks to tighten the collet. This is admittedly just a minor inconvenience for a hobbyist like myself, but I always wanted a lever-actuated collet closer like you find on a big-boy lathe for production work.

My friend Jim S. had an idea for a “ghetto” version of a lever-actuated drawbar:

Jim's 'ghetto' collet-closer
Jim's 'ghetto' collet-closer

The idea is to use a length of all thread as a drawbar, with a cam-actuated assembly that revolves with the spindle at the far left of the lathe. This isn’t quite as nice as a “real” lever-actuated collet closer where the lever doesn’t spin, but it’s a lot easier to make.

I just received some cheap 3MT collets that I’d ordered. I plan to experiment with this for a few days. If it works well, I’ll draw it up in CAD and send out to someplace like SendCutSend for a short run of parts. I figure anyone with a similar 10” or 11” Logan or South Bend lathe might also be interested in a kit to make one.

You obviously need to wait for the spindle to stop before acuating the cam, but it’s still more convenient than screwing down a drawbar for repetitive work.

Where the cam rubs should really be hardened. I’m thinking of using hardened washers to make the manufacturing as simple as possible.

The 3MT collets have a 3/8”-16TPI drawbar thread, so I’ll need to make an adapter that goes between the 1/2” all-thread and the collet. I also need to make some spacers that fits somewhat snuggly in the spindle to keep the all-thread centered.

Lastly, I think I’ll probably use this most with ID collets. But that will be another post.

I’ll post updates as I make progress.